Pizza restaurants

Tony's Pizza & Pub

4.5 336 reviews Closed 628 Stambaugh Ave, Sharon, PA 16146, United States

Discover this place

At Tony's Pizza & Pub, located in Sharon, PA, you'll find a culinary experience that resonates with warmth and nostalgia. Many diners, like Quentin H, commend the consistent quality of the pizza, which evokes memories of family gatherings and childhood favorites. Quentin notes, "It tastes the same as when my grandma would pick it up," highlighting the establishment's commitment to maintaining its classic recipes.

Guest reviews reflect a strong sense of community, with Melissa Craft sharing her joy in returning after 25 years and discovering that the pizza is just as delicious as she remembers. The friendly staff further enhance the dining experience, as noted by Brandon Hall, who appreciates the fresh ingredients and the inviting atmosphere of the pub.

For pizza lovers and those seeking a welcoming spot for a meal, Tony's Pizza & Pub offers more than just great food; it delivers a slice of hometown charm. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or to reminisce over a cold drink, this pizza parlor is a beloved staple that is sure to leave a lasting impression.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Historic

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Tony's Pizza & Pub before visiting.

Reviews for Tony's Pizza & Pub

4.5

336 reviews

100%

33%

11%

Review highlights

Based on 336 reviews

Reviews for Tony's Pizza & Pub consistently highlight its reliable quality and nostalgic appeal. Customers appreciate the enduring, classic taste of the pizza, often associating it with fond memories from childhood and family traditions. The restaurant is praised for its fresh ingredients, accurate orders, and friendly, welcoming staff, contributing to a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. Guests also enjoy the well-crafted drinks at the bar and the overall neighborhood pub vibe. Affordability and attentive service further enhance the positive experience, making Tony's a favored spot for both longtime locals and visitors seeking a satisfying meal and warm environment.

Quentin H

Jul 12, 2025

Fantastic pizza, never have caught them on a bad day. So consistently good it tastes the same as when my grandma would pick it up back in the day for us. That was the only place they ordered from I remember them saving the coupons you got on the box on their fridge.

Leonardo Nadal

Jun 28, 2025

Great food, great people can't go wrong

Jason Zahniser

Jun 23, 2025

One of my favorite places to go to as a kid. In walking distance of my parents place and it’s still great today!

Melissa Craft

May 28, 2025

I moved away for 25 years and moved back. The pizza has not changed a bit. Just as delicious as I remember when I played ball at wengler field. It reminded me of my childhood. Staff is friendly and pleasant. Food and prices are great.

Brandon Hall

May 26, 2025

Always great food and service. Everytime the order is exactly what I've ordered, it's always fresh, made with fresh ingredients. The drinks at the bar are always poured with love and the environment has a classic feel, very comfortable and friendly atmosphere. If just passing through, this place is great for a bite to eat and good conversation over a nice cold drink. Would reccomend to anyone.

Tyrone Offie

Apr 28, 2025

Tony's Pizza has been slinging that same pizza for years. You know what your gonna get. It's good pizza designed by O.G. Italians and it's good. If you never had it, try it. Don't expect it to be served up with a bunch of crazy stuff, it's old school pizza and it's good or these people wouldn't be here for like 100 years.. Thank you to the folks of Tony's for staying consistent with your recipe. See you soon... T.

Laurie Auld

Apr 26, 2025

I haven’t ordered from Tony’s in years. Just ordered the Tuesday special & it was fantastic. Had sausage & peppers on one, and it is the best sausage I’ve ever had. What a fantastic pizza! I can see why you are still in business.

Jerry Verdi

Mar 29, 2025

My family has been getting pizza there since 1964. I have been picking it up since 1979 when i got me driver's license lol. My kid are now getting it to. We live 40 mins away , only once in all these yrs have we gotten a bad pie and it was replaced with no problems. Quite possibly the next pizzas out there in my opinion with exception of home made.